Trading November 20, 2026

UnitedHealth sues US government over Medicare Advantage star ratings cut

UnitedHealth sues US government over Medicare Advantage star ratings cut
UnitedHealthMedicare AdvantageCMSstar ratingslawsuitsCVS HealthHumanahealth insurance

Nov 20 (Reuters) - UnitedHealth Group has sued the US government over its 2027 Medicare Advantage star ratings, arguing that the scores threaten imminent harm by cutting bonus payments and reducing benefits for patients.

In a complaint filed late Thursday, UnitedHealth said the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services improperly used 26 measures to calculate ratings for 45 contracts, arguing that the agency lacked statutory authority, failed to give a chance to object, or both.

UnitedHealth, the largest Medicare Advantage insurer, described the star ratings as the government’s “principal signal” to patients about plan quality. It said improperly low ratings could weaken its ability to provide preventive care and raise premiums for patients.

The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, which sits within the Department of Health and Human Services, declined to comment.

The agency released its 2027 ratings last month. Several other insurers, including Aetna parent CVS Health, have sued CMS over their ratings.

Medicare Advantage, also called Part C, allows patients who opt out of traditional Medicare to join private health plans known as Medicare Advantage Organizations. Medicare is available to people 65 and older or with disabilities.

Star ratings run from one, for poor, to five, for excellent. Plans with higher ratings receive government bonus payments that can reach hundreds of millions or billions of dollars when costs remain low.

UnitedHealth said the ratings for the 45 contracts in dispute would increase by at least 0.5 stars, and by as much as 1.5 stars, if CMS calculated them correctly.

In a statement about the lawsuit, the Eden Prairie, Minnesota-based company said: “We did not take this step lightly. We remain committed to working with CMS to modernize the Stars program and create a more durable approach to measuring quality.”

Judge recently ruled against CMS

As of Sept. 30, UnitedHealth served about 7.61 million Medicare Advantage patients, according to its latest quarterly report.

According to the American Medical Association, it holds a 30% share of the Medicare Advantage market, followed by Humana and CVS.

CVS sued over its star ratings last month, saying it could lose more than $2 billion in bonus payments and rebate retention. Humana filed a similar lawsuit in 2024.

UnitedHealth and CVS brought their lawsuits in federal court in Brunswick, Georgia.

In May, a federal judge there found that CMS had calculated an incorrect star rating for Clover Health and ordered a recalculation. US District Judge Lisa Godbey Wood, who issued that ruling, was assigned to the UnitedHealth and CVS cases.

FractLab Unlock Your Edge A proprietary strategy built to surface hidden opportunities others miss. FractLab Trade with FractLab Multi-timeframe trend detection, accumulation filters and adaptive position scaling. FractLab Try it with a guarantee Full TradingView toolkit access. 30-day money back if it is not for you. Try